The Red Line began as a promise ? a signal that Lagos was finally turning the page on its exhausting, daily commute. When the train launched on October 15, 2024, excitement surged from Agbado to the city?s heart. It wasn?t just new transport; it felt like a new Lagos. But one year later, the shine has dulled. What began with hope now tells a quieter, sobering story of strain, improvisation and fading order, reports NTAKOBONG OTONGARAN

The Red Line began as a promise. When it was flagged off on October 15, 2024, linking Lagos to its border communities in Ogun State, the excitement was unmistakable. Crowds gathered at Agbado, waving, cheering, filming the moment the sleek coaches slid out for their maiden run. It was more than the launch of a train; it felt like the city?s daily rhythm was about to change ? that the long, punishing commutes between the outskirts and the metropolis would finally soften.

For a moment, Lagos seemed to be moving with purpose. A year earlier, the Blue Line had opened with quiet elegance, shuttling passengers between Marina and Mile 2 in cool, steady comfort. If the Blue Line was the polished face of modern Lagos, the Red Line was its working-class heartbeat ? energetic, noisy, and alive.

I rode the train two days after its launch, on October 17. It felt like the beginning of something meaningful. The trip from Agbado to Oyingbo carried a shared sense of pride. Passengers chatted about how ?Eko don finally reach London level.? The hum of the engine, the smooth acceleration, the cool air conditioning, and the passing neighbourhoods framed through wide windows offered a rare Lagos moment ? a taste of what functioning public infrastructure feels like.

A little more than a year later, I returned to Agbado to see what had changed. That was Thursday, October 25. The morning sun was already pressing down on the low rooftops around the station. The terminal still rose ahead like a fortress of steel and glass. Vendors clustered at the entrance, selling snacks, cold drinks, and cash withdrawals via POS machines. It was busy ? but not chaotic. That alone felt like an achievement.

The first good news was that the trains were still running on schedule. In fact, more trips had been added, bringing daily services to nine in each direction. A staff member explained this with a tone that was part pride, part fatigue ? the kind of pride that comes from routine, not excitement. But signs of strain were visible. Ticket top-ups had been moved outside the station. Passengers now stood in the open sun to buy or refill their travel cards, queuing behind yellow tape while those traveling to Ibadan were checked in inside. The Nigerian Railway Corporation?s intercity service shares part of the Agbado terminal, and it had become clear that the two systems were still struggling to coexist.

I joined the queue, the heat sharpening slowly on my neck. The woman in front of me spoke in a low, resigned voice ? the kind that comes from repeating a complaint too many times. ?Dem say na because NRC train dey use inside. Dem no want mix people,? she said. The promise was still there ? but the shine had noticeably worn. For a system that prides itself on modern rail reform, the arrangement was a disappointing lapse in service delivery ? poor crowd management, inadequate shelter, and a general disregard for passenger comfort. It was an avoidable display of inefficiency in a facility designed to embody order, not confusion. With proper coordination, the vast Agbado station could easily accommodate all passengers.

As we waited to be called into the terminal, the man beside me leaned in and asked whether I had collected a seating card ? a way of determining who would sit and who would stand. I hadn?t understood him at first, so I showed him the card I had been given, the number ?062? written boldly across it. He nodded, satisfied. ?Good. This one mean you go sit. From 101, na standing,? he said with a knowing grin. ?Na that one we dey target first, because if seat finish, you go stand all through.? He chuckled and adjusted his bag. The casual tone made the situation seem ordinary, as though the chaos had become part of the system. But it was another reminder of how disorganized the process had become. In a properly managed rail service, seating allocation should be integrated into ticketing ? not left to handwritten numbers on small cards and passengers scrambling for ?sitting? privileges.

When we were finally ushered inside, passengers moved quietly, tapping their cards at the counter and filing through the gates onto the platform. When the train arrived, a soft murmur rippled through the crowd. We boarded with calm precision ? but within minutes, the carriages were packed beyond comfort. Every inch of space was taken; the aisle disappeared beneath a tight press of legs and backpacks. Someone muttered with a laugh, ?Na molue dem don turn this one to o.?

Days earlier, I had seen a viral video of passengers pouring out of the Red Line like commuters disembarking from a molue ? the chaotic Lagos bus of old. I had thought the video exaggerated. Now, it felt like understatement. Before the train pulled out, I walked through two adjoining coaches. It was a narrow squeeze. A young man had wedged himself between two metal luggage frames, his knees bent awkwardly as he tried to balance. The sight was both comic and painfully familiar. He caught my eye and smiled ? perhaps at my surprise.

The train?s movement was smooth, but the air-conditioning struggled. The cabin felt heavy with heat and the shared scent of bodies. My seatmate, a mason named Abdulwasiu Ganiyu, held a worn bag filled with his tools, which clanked softly each time he shifted. ?Na so e dey be,? he said. ?Sometimes, if I reach late, I go stand all the way to Mushin.?

Across from us sat Lanre, broad-shouldered and easy-tempered, chatting with two friends. As I leaned toward the window to take photographs, he laughed. ?Bros, e be like say na your first time for this train,? he said. ?I took it last year,? I replied. He laughed again, glancing at the sweat I wiped from my forehead. ?No worry,? he said, tapping the sealed window. ?Very soon dem go cut this glass make e slide like BRT. Heat no go catch person again.? The others chuckled. I smiled too ? though there was something poignant in his optimism, a quiet resignation masking itself as hope. A Lagos commuter?s survival instinct: adjust, endure, and believe change will come ? even when the system keeps proving otherwise.

As we glided past Iju, Agege, and Mushin, I was struck by how quickly the Red Line had begun to mirror the very city it was meant to transform. Like the BRT buses that launched with air-conditioned promise and soon slid into broken vents and peeling interiors, the Red Line seemed to have aged too quickly. At each stop, more passengers squeezed in as others got off. A woman carrying a baby murmured that she had left home at 6:00 a.m., yet still had to fight for space because the earlier 7:10 a.m. train had been filled beyond capacity.

A teenage boy clung to a metal pole, earbuds in, head bowed in exhaustion. The mood was familiar: weary acceptance, occasional banter, and that resilient patience Lagos breeds. When we finally pulled into Oyingbo, I exhaled. The journey had taken less than an hour, but it felt longer. The platform buzzed with movement. Some hurried off to catch connecting buses, while others paused to take photos?just as I had done a year earlier, when the Red Line felt like a miracle.

I asked a staff member whether additional schedules would be introduced to ease the strain. He offered a vague smile. ?When that happens, you will see it,? he said before walking away. Outside Oyingbo station, I crossed to the BRT park, hoping to continue to Marina. There was no bus. The cashier, who spoke fluent English but switched to Pidgin for emphasis, said, ?The one wey dey go CMS don move. I no sabi when another one go come. You fit take danfo.?

I took his advice. The danfo was cramped, jerky, and cost nearly as much as the train fare. I alighted a few metres from Lagos House, Marina, and crossed the busy expressway to the train station. At the Marina terminal, I asked one of the Last Mile drivers whether there was a direct bus to Oyingbo. He smiled and shook his head. ?No direct one, oga. You go first reach CMS, then find your way from there.?

His casual reply captured the flaw in Lagos? celebrated multimodal transport dream. How could two flagship terminals?the Blue Line at Marina and the Red Line at Oyingbo?exist without a simple, direct link? A state that prides itself on integrated mobility had left a gap at the very heart of its network. A system designed to connect rail, road, and water instead revealed a glaring mismatch.

Inside, however, the Marina station was pristine. The air was cool, staff were attentive, and the queue moved with quiet efficiency. I paid for my ticket to Mile 2 using the tap-in card system and boarded without fuss. The train was waiting?its interior spotless. A low mechanical hum, a faint scent of disinfectant, and passengers seated in calm order. It felt like stepping into a different world entirely.

The train departed within minutes. Through the windows, the Atlantic corridor rolled into view, alongside the busy corporate stretch of Marina and Broad Street. The air-conditioning hummed softly. Unlike the Red Line, this carriage felt spacious; there was room to breathe. For a moment, I could feel the rhythm of a system operating as it was designed to. The Blue Line?s schedule was impressive ? trains every 20 minutes in both directions, according to a staff member on board. No crowds pressing at the gates, no card vendors shouting outside. It was everything the Red Line had once promised to be.

As we arrived at Mile 2, a crowd had already gathered on the platform, waiting to board. Once the doors opened, passengers surged forward ? that familiar Lagos urgency, a choreography of survival. It brought to mind the city?s Danfo buses: the scramble for seats, the quick calculations, the subtle jostling for advantage. Only now, the scene unfolded inside a gleaming, modern station.

Yet amid this rush, something stood out. There was no visible system ensuring that passengers had tapped in before boarding. No staff at the entrance to the coaches, no digital verification. The assumption seemed to be that everyone on the platform had already paid. In reality, I could have stepped off, turned around, and re-entered the train back to Marina without paying anything.

It was a small detail, but a telling one ? a crack in the foundation of a network striving to build trust. Fare integrity is not just about revenue; it is about sustainability. When enforcement is lax, systems decay ? slowly at first, then all at once.

The Red and Blue Lines were designed to symbolize the Lagos of tomorrow: connected, efficient, and inclusive. On paper, they do. In practice, they reveal familiar tensions. The Red Line, meant to serve working-class commuters across Lagos and Ogun border communities, is already showing signs of the chaos it was built to correct. The Blue Line, running through the city?s commercial core, remains the polished sibling ? cooler, cleaner, calmer. The contrast is unspoken, but unmistakable.

A year into its operation, the Red Line tells a story that Lagos knows too well: a bold beginning weighed down by management fatigue and creeping neglect. The signs are quiet but visible. Card top-up points have been pushed outside the station, forcing commuters to queue under the harsh sun. Ticketing and passenger control feel improvised rather than planned. Inside, cooling systems strain against packed coaches, reducing what should be a comfortable ride into a test of endurance. And despite rising passenger demand, there is little evidence of a structured plan to increase frequency or expand capacity. The system is running, yes ? but it is running tired.

This is not to dismiss the achievement. A decade ago, the idea of two electric urban rail lines moving Lagosians daily would have sounded like hopeful fiction. Now, the Red Line and the Blue Line are physical reality ? steel laid over years of political insistence, financial negotiation, and infrastructural complexity. Lagos has shown ambition, and ambition deserves recognition. But ambition without maintenance is a slow failure. What begins as pride can quietly slip into dysfunction if ignored. Infrastructure ages; systems require adaptation; transit culture must be taught and sustained. Lagos cannot afford to repeat the story of the BRT ? launched with air-conditioned promise, now a patchwork of broken seats, shattered vents, and resigned passengers.

If Lagos is serious about building a truly multimodal transport network, it must focus not only on constructing lines but on connecting experiences. Integration should feel seamless: a commuter stepping off the Red Line at Oyingbo should be able to connect directly ? physically and digitally ? to a bus heading toward Marina, without confusion, long waits, or unnecessary discomfort. Signage, schedules, payment systems, and staff coordination are as crucial as tracks and stations. Mobility is more than movement; it is ease, predictability, and dignity.

As I left Mile 2 that afternoon, the Blue Line glided in, quiet and composed, like an assurance of what Lagos can achieve when systems are cared for. Yet my memory of the Red Line ? the heat, the crowds, the weary acceptance etched into faces ? reminded me of what Lagos too often settles for. The distance between what Lagos has built and what Lagos needs is not measured in kilometres. It is measured in management ? and the will to sustain what has already begun. (The Nation)

Update news