NLNG Corporate Caring banner First bank SME Connect Fidelity bank card banner Emerald Energy Institute Camano banner

Arguments in the Nigerian Left, By Edwin Madunagu

By on 30/04/2019

Gmail icon

Views: 515

•Edwin Madunagu
•Edwin Madunagu

The 2019 general elections provoked undeclared and unstructured discussions and debates in the Nigerian Left. Of the various themes that can be articulated from these animated exchanges of opinions – some of which are continuing – at least three may be considered central in the history and politics of revolutionary socialist struggle in Nigeria.

My interest in this article is more to help the discussions to continue – at all levels – more productively and heuristically than to take definitive positions. And I shall attempt to serve this primary interest by providing information, clarifications and reminders. I shall also recall significant insights in the earlier segments of the discussions. But I shall not attempt to moderate the discussions that had already taken place or those that are continuing.

The first theme can be called “ideological classification of politics and political formations;” the second can be titled “forms of state in the transition to socialism,” and the third is the “identification of a Marxist or a revolutionary socialist in a capitalist country like Nigeria.” The three themes, taken together, relate to the fundamental general need of the Nigerian Left to understand the society it wishes to transform and its possible directions of movement. Beyond these are the specific needs of organisation-building, tactics, strategy, alliances, manifestoes and platforms.

On the transition to socialism: The name given by Karl Marx himself to the form of state in the transition to Marxian socialism (or scientific socialism) is “dictatorship of the proletariat”. Socialism itself, as we know, would have no need of state, as state. That was the classical formulation in the second half of the 19th century. Since then world history and the concrete experiences of global socialist revolution have led to several other formulations forged by revolutionary socialists in the midst of struggle: dictatorship of the proletariat and the peasantry; people’s democracy; popular democracy; state of the whole people; etc. In one of the discussions during Elections 2019 “developmental state” came up as a possible form of state for transition to socialism. Information available to me is that developmental state is “a term used by international political economy scholars to refer to the phenomenon of state-led macroeconomic planning in East Asia in the twentieth century.”

Two important points can be raised to advance this discussion. The first has to do with the functions of the state – under capitalism. These functions, following Ernest Mandel, can be summarised under three categories: “provision of those general conditions of production which cannot be assured by the private activities of the members of the dominant class; repression of any threat to the prevailing mode of production from the dominated classes or particular sections of the dominant classes; and integration of the dominated classes, to ensure that the ruling ideology of the society remains that of the ruling class ….” (Ernest Mandel: Late Capitalism). What changes would these functions undergo in the transition to socialism? The second point is that the critical question for any transition is that of class power, that is, the dominant class character of the coalition of forces in power and the direction the transition is moving and seen to be moving under this coalition.

On the identification of a Marxist: A Nigerian Marxist recently offered the following proposition: “And, if I may add, where you work, or earn a living isn’t what makes you a revolutionary. What makes you a revolutionary is your conviction and your actions, your theory and your practice, that is, your praxis. And more importantly, in a capitalist society, what makes you a socialist or a Marxist is not your place in the mode of production—that is, whether worker, academic, petty-bourgeois, etc. but essentially your convictions, your politics, your political action ….” This is an old issue in the Nigerian Socialist Movement, especially in the Marxist subgroup. That it is again being debated now simply means either that it has not been resolved or that it has assumed new forms, or both.

On the classification of politics: Since the emergence of All Progressives Congress (APC) in 2013 and, in particular, since its victory in Nigeria’s presidential election of 2015, comparison between this ruling class party and the Peoples Democratic Party (PDP) – the ruling class party it defeated and supplanted – has remained on the agenda of the Nigerian Left. And, of course, the two parties have remained the dominant (capitalist) ruling class parties in Nigeria. This comparison logically and expectedly came up and remained a point of discussion throughout Elections 2019.

At a point a prominent Nigerian Marxist decided to telescope the discussion with two suggestions: one, that what the two ruling class parties – APC and PDP – have in common is more than what divides them; and two: that APC is a Centre-Right party while PDP is a Right Party. In other words, the two dominant ruling class (capitalist) parties – APC and PDP – though similar in several respects, are not the same. To miss this point, the Marxist insists, is to miss the critical difference between the Right and the Centre-Right (or Right of Centre) in politics. What follows is offered to assist the expansion of discussions of this important subject.

The term, Left, in politics is believed to have originated in the National Assembly of France during the first phase of the revolution (1789-1894) that put an end to the feudal and absolutist order in that country. The term was used in that revolutionary assembly to identify the radicals who were seated to the left of the presiding officer. Today, the Left is used, not only in France, but all over the world. And it is used not only to refer to or describe the more radically progressive or socialistic wing of a legislative assembly, but also to describe a political party, platform, movement or tendency, a political system, or a public policy (governmental or non-governmental) that is popular-democratic, radically progressive or socialist. Historically and logically what was left of the whole after the identification or designation of the Left became the Right and what I may call the “Ambivalent.”

New terms are introduced in the sciences (natural or social) either to capture the emergence of new things or phenomena, or to combine or aggregate separate things or phenomena that are now known to be similar or to have developed similarities in some vital respects, or to differentiate elements in phenomena or things that had previously been thought to be homogeneous. In other words, we have new terms when new things and phenomena emerge, through the process of combination and association and through the process of differentiation and separation. This is the situation in the particular system of classification of politics under discussion. But if the Left-Right differentiation in politics originated in revolutionary France, its further sub-differentiation has been and is still being spearheaded in the United States of America.

Generally, once in a political system we identify and designate the Left, we can easily define the Right; and from the Left-Right political spectrum, we can easily construct the Centre (the old “Ambivalent”). Having established the Left, the Right and the Centre, it is an elementary exercise to articulate “intermediate” positions between the Centre and the Left and between the Centre and the Right. These “intermediate” positions are designated Left-of-Centre and Right-of-Centre respectively. The former “leans to the left-wing, but closer to the centre than other left-wing politics,” while the latter “leans to the right but closer to the centre than other right-wing politics.” The Far-Left “is located further on the Left of the Left-Right political spectrum,” while the Far-Right is similarly located further on the Right. But speaking personally, I would confess that once we begin to further subdivide the Left-Centre-Right spectrum in Nigeria I also begin to have serious problems!

Edwin Madunagu, mathematician and journalist, writes from Calabar, Cross River State.

Source News Express

Posted 30/04/2019 11:40:39 AM





You may also like...
COZA breaks silence on rape saga, declares support...

Army panel faults Amnesty International, dismisses report on...

Death threat for popular Nigerian blogger

No police officer killed during our pro-Biafra march...

PDP wins 13 of 24 State Assembly seats...

2019 Presidency: Obaze doubts INEC’s neutrality, warns against...

Man lands in court for stealing chin-chin

Onaiyekan to FG: Step up security on Abuja-Kaduna...

Akpabio tasks surveyors

Court fixes Oct. 30 to hear MTN’s case...

Alleged killer vaccine: Send your children back to...

Lessons from Thomas Cook’s collapse, By Emmanuel Onwubiko...


Latest News BREAKING: APC in early lead in Bayelsa governorship election Jonathan’s kinsmen celebrate PDP’s defeat Ohanaeze loses ex-President KogiDecides2019: We shall record zero votes in areas where ballot boxes were snatched ― INEC Minimum Wage: We’re still negotiating with Labour ― Lagos Government Catholic priest kidnapped in Enugu Nigerian security forces open fire on journalists, protesters Zik’s Lecture: Koroma, Obi, Nwobodo, others harp on purposeful migration EFCC nabs brothers for ‘dupping’ Yahoo Boys Nigeria is dying ― Prof. Utomi •Says elections since 1999 have been rigged Rape suit: No court imposed N1m fine on me ― Busola Dakolo Abia: Appeal Court affirms Gov. Ikpeazu’s election victory


Most Read NUDE PHOTO OF OMOTOLA JALADE-EKEINDE surfaces online (562,808 views) Nigerian female sex addict opens up, says ‘I like it with both men and women’ (452,316 views) Shameless Genevieve Nnaji exposes breasts in public (401,444 views) Finally named: The full list of friends of Nigerian female sex addict who prowled Facebook (335,768 views) OLUMBA OLUMBA OBU (the one who called himself God) IS DEAD (303,655 views) 10 cars more expensive than Jets (281,175 views) Igbo scholar disgraces Femi Fani-Kayode •Demolishes claims on Igbo/Yoruba history with facts and figures (258,797 views) Breaking News: POPULAR REVEREND CONVERTS TO ISLAM in Kaduna (Nigeria) (256,990 views) OBJ’s son reported dead in Lagos plane crash •Names of more victims emerge (238,531 views) My wasted years in Olumba Olumba Obu’s Evil Brotherhood (224,927 views) Lagos plane crash: Journalist releases victims’ names (201,431 views) THE FINAL DISGRACE: Igbo scholar unleashes more facts about Igbo/Yoruba history, finishes off Femi Fani-Kayode with second article (198,117 views)


CBN milk production

CBN banner advert

UBA Wise Savers Promo


Categories Advertorials (3) African Press Organisation (81) Art & Literature (109) Business & Economy (4,574) Business Verdict (86) Columnists (1,144) Complaints & Requests (97) Enterprise & Opportunities (219) Entertainment (704) Features (845) Global Business Monitor (493) ICT Monitor (67) International (4,213) Interview (211) Live Commentary (30) Love Matters (176) Maggie's Blog (486) News (54,031) Opinion (1,418) Pidgin (17) Politics (11,742) Religion (1,119) Sports (2,226) Stock Watch (39) AMA & Al Jazeera Global Update







APO Group Partner




GOCOP Accredited Member

GOCOP Accredited member



Africa Media Agency and Al Jazeera